Proposed cuts to education is “blackmail”

Officers have denied “blackmailing” councillors to accept major cuts to schools’ budgets which, a new report warns, could lead to job losses and impact the quality of education in Gwynedd.
Facing a further £2m of cuts in 2020/21 following over a decade of dwindling grants from central government, members were asked to accept proposals to cut school spending by £728,080 as part of the council-wide cloth cutting exercise.
But alarmed at the scale of the cuts, councillors refused to accept the recommendation after being warned it would likely lead to a reduction in the number of teachers and/or ancillary staff, which would likely result in a detrimental impact on educational standards.
The biggest bone of contention among the proposals to save , presented to members of Gwynedd’s Education and Economy Scrutiny Committee on Thursday, is a reduction of £463,900 by amending the pupil teacher ratio  – the formula that works out how many staff are required per pupil.
But despite being told that such a move could eventually be avoided further down the line by raising council tax or if a better-than-expected central government settlement is reached, several members said they couldn’t support any measures that would weaken the county’s educational provision.
Cllr Gareth Jones said: “The potential effect this would have across the county scares me to be honest.
“It comes across as very flippant if I’m honest and I would urge officers to look at this again.” 
But the chief executive, Dilwyn Williams, said that the authority had little choice but to look at budget cuts across the board, despite repeated pleas on the Welsh Government for extra cash.
He added, “This is a very difficult situation and I understand that.
“What the officers have done is to come up with the least worst possibilities.
“Other than cutting their budgets, what other options do we have other than closing schools? If you’re not willing to cut the budget of individual schools, are you willing to consider that?”
But Cllr Alwyn Gruffydd intervened, noting that it would have a “devastating impact” on staff morale, and that morally he could not accept such cuts.
He also accused Mr Williams of “blackmailing” councillors – a claim the Chief Executive denied.
“The role of this committee to decide, from the options presented, which ones should be presented to the cabinet for consideration,” said Mr Williams.
“The proposals put forward are those, in the view of officers, that would have the least worst effect overall on the children of Gwynedd.”
Cllr Cai Larsen said that, despite having spent the majority of his career in education, “with a heavy heart” he would have to accept the findings at this stage.
“We obviously hope we won’t end up having to do these things, but doing nothing and not putting forward any view whatsoever is not really an option and makes the committee look stupid,” he added.
While members decided not to accept the recommendation of the report, their views will be considered when the cabinet debates the issue over the coming weeks.

By Gareth Williams – Local Democracy Reporter